When a Witness Recants is a moving account of an injustice that lives long beyond the sentence and a celebration of life despite the hardships and obstacles.
Set in Baltimore in 1983, 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett was murdered inside Harlem Park Junior High because he wouldn’t give up his Georgetown jacket. Three teenagers and best friends Andrew Stewart, Ransom Watkins, and Alfred Chestnut were charged and convicted of the murder. They spent 36 years in prison for a crime they did not commit and were released in part when a major witness recanted, claiming he was coerced by authorities to identify these three as the culprits.
I sat down with award-winning director Dawn Porter to talk about this documentary and why it is important.

Reggie Ponder: Why did you make me cry?
Dawn Porter: You sound like my mother. She’s like, “Oh, another comedy.” We don’t actually try to make people cry, but some stories grab you on a human level, and that’s what this story did. The first time I met these three gentlemen, something about the way they communicate was so honest and open that I thought, “These folks are gonna break through.”
People are gonna listen to them. There are a lot of stories and issues clamoring for our attention, but I thought people would spend some time with this.

Reggie Ponder: I’m riveted listening to these men. How did the way you filmed them help command that attention?
Dawn Porter: I’m very, very proud that you said that. One of the things I’ve learned over the years is you have to do two things in an interview setting, at least two major things. One is the most important thing: your subject has to be comfortable. They have to be in a space where they can actually tell their story and not be distracted or uncomfortable or restless. That’s the first thing.
The second thing is for your audience, because we all have small attention spans. And so one of the things I thought a lot about was, “I don’t want people to be able to look anywhere else.” So we filmed them in an empty place. There’s nothing else to look at but them. You have to reckon with their story.
You have to engage. And once you get used to it, it’s like reading subtitles. Once you get used to it, you kind of forget that you’re doing it, right?
Reggie Ponder: How did you create an environment that allowed them the space to express themselves?
Dawn Porter: The other thing that this accomplished was that they lived in such noisy, chaotic environments for so long, and this is one of the things I have learned over the years about doing interviews with people who’ve been incarcerated.
They all speak about the noise and the chaos, and that they cannot relax because it’s always noisy. It’s like living in hell. And so I thought, “We need to have a quiet place where they are not distracted, where they can feel safe.” And so that is part of the reason for choosing the main interview location for them, and of course, for that ultimate scene.
If you do that, it gives people who have felt powerless and ignored, it gives them some power back. That is their environment. They control what is said, how it’s said. They control it a little bit more. And that’s how you are respectful to your subjects. And when you are respectful to your subjects,
then if you’re lucky, you get the kind of intimacy that you want, and that is ultimately better for their stories.
Reggie Ponder: Hearing about their sacrifices is a gut punch. What were you feeling behind the camera, not while editing, but while filming?
Dawn Porter: If you notice, I didn’t have them describe the violence of prison. And that is intentional, because what I was interested in is the interior. What did your mind feel like? What were your emotions? I’ll tell you, I have two kids. I have two boys, and they’re in their 20s now.
And a lot of the time when I’m doing these interviews, I’m thinking about their (the subjects’) parents and about how helpless I would feel if I could not protect my child. That’s what I was thinking a lot of. Even though I’m looking at 50-something-year-old men, I’m feeling like they’re 16 and I need to stop this before it ruins their lives.
That’s what I was thinking a lot. And, you know, it’s funny, Ransom will say, “Dawn was, like, motherly to us.” I was like, “What do you mean?” But I know what he means, because that’s probably how I was. I was so frustrated with what they were saying. You kind of learn over time when you’re doing interviews: it’s okay to have facial expressions. You need to be quiet so that you don’t interrupt their stories, but sometimes I would cry. Sometimes I would just be so frustrated that I’d be, like, clenching my teeth.
Reggie Ponder: How did the people behind the camera contribute to your ability to connect with these men?
Dawn Porter: I work with really, really strong people. And so Brian Gentry is a young-ish (he’s gonna get mad at me now) Black man.
But all the main cinematographers I work with, Keith, Brian, Bryant, they are all empaths. And so they’re not just excellent at
capturing images; they are emotional men. It’s like a dance, and they’re in tune with the guys and where the guys are going.
So, I don’t have to worry that it’s gonna look great. I check the image at the beginning and the middle, but I can really focus on whom I’m talking to and give them my full attention. That is the greatest respect we can give somebody: full attention. I’m not looking at a phone; I’m not looking at papers.
I’m looking at nothing but them. And I think it’s so rare that that happens that people respond to you. They’re like, “Okay, let me take this opportunity to explain. Nobody’s gonna cut me off. Nobody’s gonna rush me.” So I think it’s all those things together.

Reggie Ponder: How does this story about yesterday speak to oppression today?
Dawn Porter: That’s a very meaningful question, and I think it’s very hard for average citizens who have not been impacted by the criminal legal system to even fathom that somebody is sitting in prison for something they didn’t do. You just cannot wrap your mind around it. We are taught from… When you’re two years old, what do you say? “That’s not fair.” Right? Fairness is, like, an American kind of tenet. It is just something that we are taught that we deserve, and we expect it is going to happen. So, you know, part of my job is saying, “This does
happen.” And the reason people also don’t wanna believe it happens is because it’s terrifying.
Because you think if you don’t do anything, you’re not part of these people. You don’t have to care about this. And when someone says, “Mm-mm, it could happen to you or your child,” it’s terrifying, and so people turn away. So if you can tell this story in a way that helps people understand how it happens..
.
Reggie Ponder: We hear a lot about one bad apple, but it’s clear that this film rejects that narrative.
Dawn Porter: That’s one of the things I love about this film. This is not one rogue cop. He did his part, but then the prosecutors didn’t listen, and the judge who sentenced them spoke to them, as Andrew says, and I will never forget it, like they were trash. “He spoke to us like we were trash.” And then the appeals didn’t work, but they didn’t give up.
Trying and trying and trying until it did happen. That’s what we mean by systemic oppression. We mean targeting people who are poor. We mean assuming that they have done something illegal, immoral, or both, and then not listening to them when they cry for help. That is oppression.
Their families were not listened to and not believed, so we had a whole class of people who were not given the same respect for their truth-telling that a wealthier or whiter group of people would have been given. Nobody was hearing them. They were shouting into the wind.
Reggie Ponder: What does forgiveness mean in this film?
Dawn Porter: Forgiveness is a theme that runs throughout this film. What does it mean? Who can ask for it? Can you ever really accomplish it? Is it something we should even be asking people to do? So, there’s forgiveness of the people who testified against them. There’s forgiveness of the families who just
couldn’t keep up with visits or support the way that you would hope a family could.
There’s forgiveness of themselves for responding to the situations and the circumstances of prison with what that demanded. Ransom talks about how he felt like an animal, and he said, “I’m gonna act like an animal for now.” Can you imagine being a teenager and saying, “This is not who I am, but this is who I have to be if I’m going to live”?
No one should be put into that position. And by the way, that is whether you did something or not. No one should be put in the position of feeling like they are an animal. Like, what that does to your mind. He will never get over the guilt of defending himself. So, there’s all of that.
Reggie Ponder: I wanted a forgiveness that was loving. And while you showed a healing steeped in hope, you also gave us a pain wrapped in part in anger. Can you speak to that?
Dawn Porter: I think there’s another element to forgiveness, which is: what do we want as an audience? We want a neat story where everybody hugs it out, and they say, “I’m your brother. I’m your brother,” and there’s, you know, violins or cellos, depending on your, your preference. And that’s not what happens.
But there is maybe not complete forgiveness, but there is some healing. My takeaway now, and this is just my opinion, is that they were probably afraid of their anger, afraid that they would only be angry. And once they were allowed to express the anger, they realized they didn’t have to fear it.
They could be angry and also continue to live and not be consumed with anger. And so I think that was actually one of the most meaningful things to happen. It wasn’t what we all expected would happen, but maybe it was the best thing to happen. They could actually verbalize, “This is what this did to
me, and I’m afraid I’m never gonna be the same,” and they could then kind of move on.
And they are so much better right now. They will all say, “We don’t know if we’re ever gonna be fully healed,” whatever that means. But I see how much calmer they are. There’s a lot more light, laughter, love. That’s why I say, what are we asking of people?
Reggie Ponder: Part of my crying was hearing that phone call to Mom, saying, “Look, I’m coming out.”
Dawn Porter: He says, “I’m coming home to you.”
And she says, “You’re coming home to me?” I mean, that gets me every single time. Then the one tear, that’s what a great camera person saw: the tear without interrupting the scene. He’s listening to a call that was years earlier that he keeps, and then he could play it, and she hadn’t heard it.
He kept it for himself. There’s so much happening in that little scene, and, you know, when he says, “That’ll melt your heart right there,” I think he wants it known that his heart can be melted, that he’s not cold and dead. He wants to convey that even if you feel pain, it means that you can feel.
Reggie Ponder: Ta-Nehisi Coates talks about being heard. That seems so important to what you do. Can you talk about that?
Dawn Porter: When we did the last interview with Ta-Nehisi, there’s something he says in his Baltimore accent: “The least we can do is give these brothers their story.”
And that really affected me, how he said that. You know, Ta-Nehisi as a writer, as a philosopher, as a thinker… And to give someone their story means you kind of elevate them to a place where they understand that they are worthy, they are important, they’re not forgotten, and what happened to them mattered.
I think about this also a lot as a Black filmmaker. A lot of stories about people who’ve been incarcerated can be kind of flat. Like, dwell on the violence of prison. This is about them. This is the interior of all those years and how they’re reckoning with that.
And so, that’s really hearing people because in a lot of ways we don’t wanna hear it because it’s inconvenient to our ordering of the world that those things don’t happen, they get corrected, they never happened in the first place. It’s painful to live with the fact that people are sent to prison for something they didn’t do. It’s just painful.
Reggie Ponder: What did you leave on the cutting room floor that you wish you could have kept?
Dawn Porter: What we really left out was a lot of that end meeting.
That meeting was more than an hour long. In the film, it’s much shorter than that, so we left a lot of detail out.
There’s a lot more about Ron’s art that I was really intrigued by. He has a basement full of paintings. He’s almost like a compulsive painter. And I was really curious about what that does for him. I’m very interested in the role of art, of making it, thinking about it, all forms of art. I made a film with Amy Sherald once and was talking to her about her process, and she painted Breonna Taylor, and she said that she had never painted a person who wasn’t alive before. And so she was, like, speaking to Breonna and asking her to help her. Isn’t that interesting? Because she said she usually feeds off of people’s energy. That’s how she creates her images. Isn’t that interesting?
Reggie Ponder: Yes. Yeah.

Dawn Porter: I’m not able to make beautiful paintings, and I’m kind of curious about the people who can.
Reggie Ponder: Why should people watch this documentary?
Dawn Porter: I hope people will watch When a Witness Recants because it shows one of the most egregious cases of wrongful incarceration, and it features three of the most resilient, emotional storytellers who grace us with their stories.
So I hope people will, and I think people will, connect with them in a way that is on such a human level. I think it restores your faith to understand that people like this could suffer such injustices and still come out gracious, grateful, and honorable.
Reggie Ponder: How have they reacted to watching this film and reliving their story on screen?
Dawn Porter: I have loved traveling with them, and they have said that watching this film, even though it’s hard, they watch it every single time.
I don’t watch it because I’m like you. I get too upset in the middle. I get too mad. But they watch it, and they said watching people respond and care and cry is helping them heal. They’re rebuilding their trust in people just because people care. So watch it because your watching it will help them to heal, and it’s like Ta-Nehisi said, “The least we can do is give these brothers their story.”
Their story, When a Witness Recants, debuts Tuesday, November 17 on HBO and will be available to stream on HBO Max.